FML Brackets: Star Wars vs Pulp Fiction

Patrick Reardon · February 27, 2017 · 7:07 pm PST

Over the past 10 days, our all-time Oscar bracket, "The Godfather" proved to be the "best" Best Picture winner, beating out "Schindler's List" in the finals. Honestly. We didn't let Warren Beatty and Faye Dunaway anywhere near our voting tabulations. But enough about the winners. What about the losers?

The crop of films that have been nominated for Best Picture (but didn't win) is arguably better than the group of films that actually won the big prize. But which one of these Best Picture losers is the BEST film? We're going to let the Fantasy Movie League community decide.


-All films that were nominated for Best Picture but didn't win were eligible. We limited it to no more than three losing films for any given year.

-Once we had our list of 64 finalists they were seeded according to the following formula:

Rotten Tomato score + IMDB user score (x10) + Egregiousness Factor = Final Score

-A little explanation on the "Egregiousness Factor." Each film was given a score from 1 (least egregious) through 5 (most egregious). For example, although "The Wizard of Oz" is a cinematic classic there was no shame in losing to "Gone With the Wind," so it scored a 1. However, every few years we have a "Goodfellas" losing to "Dances With Wolves" or a "Saving Private Ryan" losing to "Shakespeare in Love." Those types of films scored a 5.

Cast your votes, spread the word and make a case for your favorite Best Picture losers in the chatter.

If you are on the FML App, you can view the bracket on Brackify: Best of the Rest


Post New Topic

Be the first to post a new message
Post New Topic

More Insider

  • FML Brackets: Scarlett Johansson
    Patrick Reardon· Mar 28, 2017

    Scarlett "don't call her ScarJo" Johansson has had roles in mega blockbusters and arthouse favorites in her career thus far. Which one was best?

  • Week 5 Box Office Estimates
    Todd Thatcher· Mar 28, 2017

    A look at estimated box office for this week's slate of movies.